The Drift: The Role of Women and Men

In our new series called "The Drift," we're examining how theology has morphed and changed since the first century due to cultural influences and misinterpretations of biblical text. Today, we're tackling the often-controversial topic of the roles of women and men in ministry.

Two Unhealthy Extremes in Church Ministry

When it comes to gender roles in ministry, churches often fall into one of two unhealthy extremes:

Some churches completely silence women, taking Paul's words to specific local churches as universal commands for all women, everywhere, for all time.

Other churches allow men to drift into spiritual laziness, leaving women to do the heavy lifting of church work.

Both extremes miss the truth. God designed men and women to minister alongside each other.

What Does Paul Actually Say About Women Speaking in Church?

Let's examine the passages often used to restrict women in ministry:

1 Corinthians 14:34-35 "The women should keep silent in the churches, for they are not permitted to speak, but should be in submission. As the law also says, if there is anything they desire to learn, let them ask their husbands at home, for it is shameful for a woman to speak in church."

1 Timothy 2:11-12 "Let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man. Rather, she is to remain quiet."

Reading these verses in isolation seems clear-cut. But this is biblical literalism and it has often gotten us into trouble with understanding gender roles in ministry.

Understanding the Historical Context of Paul's Letters

The 1 Corinthians passage was written to a specific church where worship had become chaotic. Paul was establishing good order in worship, not just for women but for everyone. In that context, women had little formal education and were disrupting services with questions and interjections. Paul's solution was practical for that situation: have them ask their educated husbands at home.

The First Timothy passage was addressing the church in Ephesus where false teaching was rampant. Paul was saying people should learn before they teach. This was a situational correction, not a universal rule.

Paul's Broader View of Women in Ministry

Looking at the broader context of Paul's writings reveals a different picture:

- Paul commended Phoebe as a deacon, using the same Greek word he used to describe himself

- He praised Priscilla and Aquila as co-workers, with Priscilla leading a church in her home

- He called Junia "outstanding among the apostles"

- Acts 18:26 shows Priscilla and Aquila teaching Apollos "the way of God more accurately"

- 1 Corinthians acknowledges wives who pray and prophesy

- Acts 2:17-18 states God will pour out His Spirit on "sons and daughters" who will prophesy

Clearly, Paul affirmed women as prophets, teachers, apostles, and leaders. His restrictions to specific churches were situational corrections, not universal rules for all time.

Paul's Challenge to Men

While affirming women in ministry, Paul also challenges men in 1 Corinthians 16:13: "Be watchful. Stand firm in the faith. Act like men, be strong."

This is a military call to action:

- Be watchful: Stay spiritually awake

- Stand firm in the faith: Hold the line, don't compromise

- Act like men: Show biblical manhood (with Jesus as our example)

- Be strong: Lead with courage

The Crisis of Male Leadership in the Church

Over centuries, men have stepped back from church leadership, saying, "Church isn't for me" or leaving spiritual matters to their wives. Many men have become consumers of church rather than drivers of it.

The reality is that women are leading churches today largely because men have become absent and apathetic. The majority of church volunteers worldwide are women because men believe they have "better things to do."

This passive approach contradicts Paul's call for men to be watchful, firm in faith, and strong. Our world needs men who will step up and lead with Christlike love—not with ego or domination, but with sacrifice and responsibility.

God's Design for the Church

God's design is clear:

- Women are ministers of the gospel who should preach, teach, and lead like Phoebe, Priscilla, and Junia.

- Men need to stop being passive and start carrying the light of Christ everywhere they go.

Imagine a church where women are fully unleashed to use their gifts and where men stand tall with courage and responsibility. That's God's design. Men and women carrying the message of the gospel together, shoulder to shoulder.

Life Application

This week, consider how you might be contributing to "the drift" in your own life and church:

- For women: Are you using your God-given gifts fully? Have you allowed others' misinterpretations of scripture to silence your voice or limit your ministry? How might you step more confidently into your calling this week?

- For men: Where have you been passive in your faith? Are you leading spiritually in your home and church, or have you delegated that responsibility to others? What's one step you can take this week toward being watchful, standing firm, and leading with Christlike love?

- For everyone: How can we better support each other as equal ministers of the gospel? What practical steps can we take to create a church community where both men and women are fully empowered to use their gifts side by side?

-

The call is clear! It's time to return to biblical truth, not what we've changed it to say to fit our agendas. Let's commit to being a church where all believers, regardless of gender, are unleashed to fulfill their God-given purpose.

Devotional